View Issue Details

IDProjectCategoryView StatusLast Update
0021013MMW 5Generalpublic2024-10-23 17:09
ReporterLudek Assigned To 
PriorityimmediateSeveritymajorReproducibilityrandom
Status closedResolutionfixed 
Product Version5.0 
Target Version5.1Fixed in Version5.1 
Summary0021013: Slow startup time with debug builds
DescriptionFor me MediaMonkey starts in 4 seconds (debug build), 2 seconds (non-debug)..

But in some environments (Zvezdan/Peke) it can take up to 20 seconds to start debug build!!

From the Zvezdan's logs it takes more than 8 seconds before MediaMonkeyEngine.exe is loaded from the SSD/HDD into memory (to see first debug line from the processes)
The issue is that MediaMonkeyEngine.exe has 28 MB and it is loaded three times (two utility processes and one renderer process):

MediaMonkeyEngine.exe --type=utility --utility-sub-type=network.mojom.NetworkService
MediaMonkeyEngine.exe --type=utility --utility-sub-type=storage.mojom.StorageService
MediaMonkeyEngine.exe --type=renderer

The idea to improve this could be to make a smaller MediaMonkeyEngine.exe version for the utlitity processes (supposing it is possible in Chromium)
or (ideally) ged rid of the two utility processes altogether.
TagsNo tags attached.
Fixed in build3032

Relationships

related to 0020810 closedpetr Startup takes 10 seconds (performance) 
related to 0021015 closedLudek MM do not close completely in some cases 
related to 0020991 closedLudek MM5 is too slow with files from Folders 
related to 0020639 closedLudek Changing criteria in auto-playlists doesn't update tracklist always 
related to 0021289 closedLudek Performance: MM debug takes twice as long to close as to open 

Activities

Ludek

2024-06-11 20:00

developer   ~0075904

Last edited: 2024-06-11 20:01

@Petr: Is it possible for the two utility processes use MediaMonkeyEmbedded.exe (just 1.2 MB) instead of MediaMonkeyEngine.exe (28 MB) ??
This should reduce startup time significantly.

Zvazdan's logs in private note ~75891

zvezdan

2024-06-11 21:55

updater   ~0075910

Cleared Portable folder with empty db, Home screen displayed on start, time to show up + time when it was responsive to open a menu:
- without DebugView - 13 + 3 seconds;
- with DebugView - 23 + 14 seconds.

Ludek

2024-06-12 14:31

developer   ~0075920

Debug output times improved in 3031, left assigned to Petr to optimize JS loading times (by having all JS files in a single ZIP)

peke

2024-06-12 14:57

developer   ~0075924

Last edited: 2024-06-12 15:02

As requested here are my test steps:
1. Download https://www.passmark.com/products/apptimer/
2. Setup AppTimer According to PIC1 (Paths to EXE and LOG files May Differ according to your system)
3. Use RUN APP to measure RUN time

Repeat 1-3 process with DBGview started (change LOG file name in order to have both logs)

Test Note: Used /nosplash command line as Splash screen have same Window name as main app and influence the result

No DBGview: 21.5921 (27.26 till first mouse click was executed in Main MM screen [clicked on Menu])
With DBGview: 21.2235 (34.19 till first mouse click was executed in Main MM screen [clicked on Menu])

EDIT: Clean portable Same results, but after few starts Windows prefetched/cached exe so it is lowered to 11.3568 (14.78 on menu click) without DBGview Started. NON debug EXE starts in <10s
PIC1.jpg (42,767 bytes)   
PIC1.jpg (42,767 bytes)   
AppTimer LOGS.rar (5,811 bytes)

peke

2024-06-15 01:42

developer   ~0075985

Can you recheck with 3031.

I have found the reason for me. Ryzen Master said my CPU and Motherboard was set to CPU AMD ECO POWER SAFE MODE After Firmware update, this resulted that only 8 of 24 CPU cores work I have reset Factory Defaults for MB and CPU now MM starts normally.
C:\MediaMonkey 5\MediaMonkey.exe - 1 executions
5.0256

Ludek

2024-06-15 12:38

developer   ~0075991

Last edited: 2024-06-15 12:53

In 3031 the startup debug ouput was reduced a lot so that running DbgView is not slowing MM start so much..

But I have found that the most significant slowdowns are caused by compilation with Eureka, even debug builds that are compiled without Eureka are fast enough..
So it is about optimizing Eureka (some Eureka settings like disabling "range checks" or "overflow checks" https://docwiki.embarcadero.com/RADStudio/Athens/en/Compiling )

@Zvezdan / @Peke: I wonder what's your start time with non-debug builds?

zvezdan

2024-06-15 13:18

updater   ~0075992

@Peke - thanks for the info about AppTimer, but I am just wondering, how did you get the time till first mouse click was executed, even so on the second decimal?

zvezdan

2024-06-15 16:00

updater   ~0075993

Last edited: 2024-06-15 16:01

Here are my new tests. I tested 3029 again because I wanted to compare them in the similar conditions. I did the previous tests with the system running about 120 days without restart, only hibernation, so maybe it had something related to the fragmented memory. I made these new tests a few days after restart.

All tests with the Home view, unless one test with Folders. Many tests are with the Maximum processor state set to 99%, because the fan in my laptop could be annoying on 100%. Averaged values after at least 5 measuring with the same version/condition.

3029 - debug (99%):
22 sec (29.6 sec for opened menu)

3029 - no debug (99%):
11.2 sec (12 sec)

3031 - no debug (99%):
11.3 sec (12.2 sec)

3031 - no debug (100%):
6.4 sec (7.3 sec)

3031 - debug (99%):
15.2 sec (18 sec)

3031 - debug (99%, folder 30 albums, 229 files):
14.3 sec (29.3 sec)

3031 - debug (100%):
8 sec (7.7 sec)

3031 - release (100%):
2.3 sec (3 sec)

3031 - release (99%):
3.9 sec (4.5 sec)

So, the 3031 with DebugView is significantly faster than 3029. For example, it is 18 sec vs 29.6 sec for 99%. They are quite similar without DebugView.

Ludek

2024-06-15 18:21

developer   ~0075997

Last edited: 2024-06-17 21:12

ok, so debug messages reduction during startup helped, it is still quite surprising that 99% is twice slower than 100%
Anyhow further tweaks to Eureka compilation should improve it further..

Some tips: https://support.eurekalog.com/Knowledgebase/Article/View/92/0/7x-my-application-runs-very-slowly-with-eurekalog

peke

2024-06-15 23:57

developer   ~0075999

@zvezdan re 0021013:0075992
This time I had phone running stop watch next to top left of monitor, then recorded Slowed motion video (240 frames a second) with my other phone, and once menu opens I written the time on the phone and deduct time start time when I clicked on run app in AppTimer.

Usually I use Hardware recording (AMD GPU), but driver was quirking recently and would not want to use recording to RAM Disk.

After I done resets my RAM timings and put CPU into High performance I get results same as @Zvezdan for Release builds on clean Library and 3-4 Average on my full library and entire library -> all tracks -> list view (10k+ of tracks).

NOTE: After few MM restarts Windows prefetch EXE file and it partially loads from memory dump so I get 1.750 - 2.180 startup time to empty Playing view.

Ludek

2024-06-18 13:38

developer   ~0076039

Further findings are that using ecc32speed.exe post-compiler does the trick to make it much faster: https://www.eurekalog.com/help/eurekalog/index.php?post_process_compilers.php
So we might want to try ecc32speed.exe instead of ecc32.exe for the next builds..

Ludek

2024-06-18 14:40

developer   ~0076043

Fixed in 3032

peke

2024-07-24 18:05

developer   ~0076405

re Verified 3039

Non debug: <2s
Debug build: around 3s (varies from start to start) and <5s with DBGView opened.