View Issue Details

IDProjectCategoryView StatusLast Update
0004914MMW v4Now Playingpublic2009-03-11 22:07
Reporterpeke Assigned To 
PriorityhighSeveritymajorReproducibilityalways
Status closedResolutionnot fixable 
Summary0004914: Audio CD Playback fails when unexpected CD is in NP list
DescriptionHardware requiroments:
2x CD/DVD-Roms or Burners

Steps to reproduce:
1. insert Audio CD
2. add CD into the library
3. Start Playback of audio CD
4. Stop Playback and exit MM
5. Eject CD From CD
6. Start MediaMonkey
7. Insert CD in Second CD/DVD Drive
8. Start Playback

MM will Skip playback with an error like CD is not inserted. If I try to replicate Same Steps in MM 2.x CD will Play.
Additional InformationSample Image uploaded to FTP
TagsNo tags attached.
Fixed in build

Relationships

related to 0004927 closedLudek Regression: Seeking doesn't work when playing audio CDs 

Activities

Ludek

2008-11-13 12:56

developer   ~0014931

Last edited: 2008-11-13 13:04

Peke, I cannot reproduce your issue. Which build you tested?

But I found another regression: 0004927

peke

2008-11-13 15:28

developer   ~0014935

Retested with 1192 and it remains same.

Ludek

2008-11-13 16:01

developer   ~0014936

As discussed over IM:

This is only 'Now Playing' issue, NP points to H:\Track01.cda, but this is all right I think (same as in MM 3.0). NP should remember the last played song's path. I think that if someone want to start playing the CD from another drive, he should re-add it to the now playing?
I think this is not a regression.

Marked as resolved for Rusty to test / make a decision.

peke

2008-11-14 04:13

developer   ~0014949

@Ludek,
Yes, you are right it looks that this is only NP issue.
Using your assumption I have also found few more similar bugs regarding NP updating unavailable/available tracks how NP handles multi CD/DVD systems.

@Rusty
May I suggest that we deffer this for post 3.1 as this is looks not as easy as I firstly thought and it needs though testing for all cases where MM misses Correct show of Now playing. I've added another Screen shot where it is clearly seen that MM did not updated NP but even gray Track is Playable as Accessible.

jiri

2009-02-12 10:29

administrator   ~0016635

Based on the description, it looks like something that isn't really well fixable.

rusty

2009-03-11 22:07

administrator   ~0017065

Closing.