View Issue Details
| ID | Project | Category | View Status | Date Submitted | Last Update |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0013957 | MMA | Synchronization | public | 2017-01-27 14:16 | 2017-02-07 05:17 |
| Reporter | rusty | Assigned To | |||
| Priority | immediate | Severity | major | Reproducibility | always |
| Status | closed | Resolution | fixed | ||
| Product Version | 1.3.0 | ||||
| Target Version | 1.3.0 | Fixed in Version | 1.3.0 | ||
| Summary | 0013957: Tracks don't match to the displayed track | ||||
| Description | With build 667, I can easily create a situation in which the user clicks taps track A to play it, but track B plays instead. e.g. Click 'Strong world' --> 'Od Yishama' plays Log ID: 4BTYFTHMRB Here's how: 1 Sync 4 playlists (New Downloads, Grad Party, Party Background, Shlomo Katz) + 1 Artist (MMW build 1824): --> they sync, display, and play correctly 2 Uninstall MMA, and delete the /MediaMonkey directory 3 Reinstall MMA and configure an identical sync profile except deselect the 'Shlomo Katz' playlist + the Artist from the sync profile --> New sync profile is created 4 Sync --> Files appear to match-sync/delete as expected --> Upon playing tracks almost all are mismatched! It would appear that there's a regression in the matching algorithm. Note: - I suspect that this may be the same problem as I'd identified in 0013881 (though at that time, I'd misidentified the cause). - I also tested upgrading from 1.2.624 to 1.3.667 and that worked correctly even after multiple sync. The problem only seems to occur when matching is triggered. | ||||
| Tags | No tags attached. | ||||
| Fixed in build | 671 | ||||
|
|
Note, further testing shows that I can replicate the problem with the following simpler set of steps: 1 Sync 2 playlists (New Downloads, Shlomo Katz): --> they sync, display, and play correctly 2 Uninstall MMA, and delete the /MediaMonkey directory from the device and the device profile in MMW 3 Reinstall MMA --> All tracks play correctly 4 Configure an identical sync profile and Wi-Fi sync --> Sync dialog prompts to delete 'Niggun Nevo' for some reason 5 Accept deletion --> 3 Files resync including 'Niggun Nevoh' (it look like it synced twice) and 'Ana Avda' 6 Attempt to play the files in New Downloads playlist --> 'Or Ka'ze' displays but 'Oh Yeah' plays. Many tracks in both playlists exhibit the same problem. --> Note that the problem also occurs when playing Tracks directly (i.e. not via a Playlist) Debug log: JQWQSCE5P7 |
|
|
ote, further testing shows that I can replicate the problem with the following simpler set of steps: 0 Install MMA and verify that DB is empty Debug log SKYBVHLQ65 1 Configure sync settings in MMA Debug log: H85BLRKJ2R 1.1 Enable auto-conversion for all files > 192kbps in the sync profile in MMW 1.2 Sync 2 playlists (New Downloads, Shlomo Katz): Debug log: VIDVB79NAN --> they sync, display, and play correctly (verified with about 6 tracks in 'New downloads' playlist) 2 Uninstall MMA, and delete the /MediaMonkey directory from the device and the device profile in MMW --> After a couple of minutes, verified that the /MediaMonkey directory deleted as expected 3 Reinstall MMA and verify that tracks appear as expected Debug log: 2R67EGHEDB --> All tracks play correctly (though ratings are missing as expected) 4 Configure an identical sync profile in MMA then Enable auto-conversion for all files > 192kbps in the sync profile in MMW, and initiate Wi-Fi sync --> Sync dialog prompts to delete 'Niggun Nevo' for some reason 5 Accept deletion --> 3 Files resync ('Ana Avda', 'Hazorim', and 'Niggun Nevoh' (not sure why--they were already on the device) Debug log: TV5WQ3XTPM 6 Attempt to play the files in New Downloads playlist --> 'Strong World' displays but 'Petit Roi' plays. --> 'Or Ka'ze' displays but 'Oh Yeah' plays. --> Many tracks in both playlists exhibit the same problem. --> Also, I didn't notice this previously, but: - the song 'Ima Aba Vekol Hashar' is missing from the 'New downloads' playlist and from the Tracks list in MMA! - the songs Yahrzeit Niggun and ???? appear in duplicate (one with ratings and the other without--implying a matching problem) - the song 'Ima Aba Vekol Hashar' (along with a bunch of other tracks that aren't on the sync list) appear in another directory called primary:Music/ !! --> Note that the problem also occurs when playing Tracks directly (i.e. not via a Playlist) Debug log: B77HRQF3EP |
|
|
Fixed in build 668 There were two issues: 1. regression with document ID caused pairing issues 2. long term issue that I have found too - the pairing wasn't working correctly probably for a long time - because it was hard to find it. The sync looks correct but the audio doesn't match the metadata. |
|
|
Verified 668. The only strange issue is that as with previous tests above: After step 4 --> Sync dialog prompts to delete 'Niggun Nevo' for some reason After step 5 --> 3 Files resync ('Ana Avda', 'Hazorim', and 'Niggun Nevoh' (not sure why--they were already on the device) Is this a bug? Any idea why this happens (all of the tracks on the shlomo katz playlist are FLAC (and > 192kbps) thereby matching the autoconversion rules, so why is only 1 deleted, and why are 3 resynced? One would expect that if 1 file was deleted because it failed to match then only 1 file would be recopied OR that if 3 files needed to be recopied then 3 files should have been deleted due to failed matches. Debug log before sync: A6IDAM5AIE Debug log after sync: 6Q7ZCWADHG |
|
|
Tested build 670, and in addition to the problems described at 0013957:0047120, after step 5, MMA displays both playlists in duplicate. Log IRV3TYN8GK EDIT: to clarify - it seems as if MMA syncs the playlist without recognizing that the original playlists (from step 1.2) are already there--as if the playlists failed to match. Subsequent sync operations update the synced playlist, but fail to delete the original .m3u playlist. |
|
|
Re 0013957:0047197 : It was fixed in build 471. MMW probably process Playlist and Media paths slightly differently. So I had to fix conversion of document id to path that is processed by MMW. Re 0013957:0047120 : This is slightly more complicated. Rusty, the behaviour is correct and you don't have to generate MMW log 1. Niggun Nevoh - There is duplicate in MMW library with two different IDs: 15472 and 5877. The track is paired with 15472 but 5877 is on sync list. 2. Ana avda - This track is twice in synclist so I overlooked first time that the pairing failed for one of them. 3. Hazorim - pairing failed. Maybe due to apostrophe sign ?? Hazor & apos ; im |
|
|
Verified 671. |
