0016294: Auto Tag: Auto Tag various issues - MantisBT

ID	Project	Category	View Status	Date Submitted	Last Update

0016294	MMW 5	Tagging / organizing (properties / auto-tools)	public	2020-01-24 01:09	2020-05-23 23:10

Reporter	peke	Assigned To
Priority	urgent	Severity	minor	Reproducibility	have not tried
Status	closed	Resolution	fixed
Product Version	5.0
Target Version	5.0	Fixed in Version	5.0

Summary	0016294: Auto Tag: Auto Tag various issues
Description	1. Currently There is no way to tag only Date Or Album and leave Other tags untouched. Auto Tag do not allow selection of columns and do noy allow TAG & CONTINUE till Title Column is selected. Expected to be able to select Date Column only or Exclude Genre from tagging. That is available on Discogs plugin (Not whole Column but each field can be deselected) 2. Disk # Not available In Columns. Expected that in Auto Tag available columns are same as in Track list -> Right click Column Header. Even if current Auto Tag Script do not support them it is most likely that in Future plugin would be developed to fill that exact fields 3. Crashes in some cases when editing Album/Album artist in First Column (bug16294_3.jpg) 4. Maybe editing First Column Album/Artist Should Auto Select all tracks Assigned to that album, Currently changes all values but do not change selection 5. Edit First Column Album/Artist -> Delete content -> Enter to confirm change. You can't enter edit anymore. 6. There should be also Check mark on First column as in case user wants to Refine search by Manually Entering Album/Artist for Multiple tracks and do refresh of search it is not possible it needs to be done one by one 7. Right Click on Column it should contain Context Menu to support Mass edit of that Column eg. Edit Album -> Drop edit field -> Confirm Change -> All tracks in Auto Tag are affected and new proposed value is added to them. Example: Right click on Album Column -> Enter: Greatest Hits -> Confirm -> in All tracks is added "Greatest hits". Same is expected for First Column but would list both Album artist and Album for edit. 7.1. If added Context Menu should also contain "Refresh Data" or "Search Data". So that user can directly init Lyrics Search 7.2. If added Context Menu should also contain Multiple searched Data supplied as submenu eg. For Album Column it would contain same values as Album DropDown. 8. First Column name should be renamed to "Album Summary" or just "Summary" as if you have also Album Column enabled you have duplicate columns 9. If Album Art is not found for the album User can't click on Default Album Art Image to Lookup Image or manually Load Image (bug16294_9.jpg) 10. As Proposed Genre search can result in "Genre" as suggestion which should be ignored (bug16294_10.jpg) 11. Auto Tag: Should have DropDown Selection to modify Look of Dialog (Selected Columns) based on Type (TV, Music, Classical Music) as Searched fields are completely different
Tags	No tags attached.
Attached Files	bug16294_3.jpg (182,414 bytes) bug16294_3.jpg (182,414 bytes) bug16294_10.jpg (92,493 bytes) bug16294_10.jpg (92,493 bytes) bug16294_9.jpg (29,727 bytes) bug16294_9.jpg (29,727 bytes)

Fixed in build	2251

peke 2020-01-24 02:32 developer ~0056192	Please triage priority.

rusty 2020-05-21 22:14 administrator ~0058168	Petr: 8. It sounds reasonable to change the 'Album' heading to 'Artwork' + 'Summary' to match the [List (by Album)] views. Is this trivial to implement? 9. Agreed. If album art can't be found, user should be able to click the "blank" image to lookup/choose alternative artwork. Is this trivial to implement? Peke: 1. Per-field lookups is tracked as a future improvement at 0016640 2. Agreed: Disc # should be displayed and recommended (if > 1 CD in the set). Added at 0016641 3. I'm not seeing crashes any longer. Can you still replicate? 4. I don't think that changing selection would be expected if the user edits Album Artist / Album. 5. I'm not sure what you mean, but I've noted a problem with this functionality at 0016642 6. I suppose a refresh button would accomplish the same thing. Tracked at 0016640 7. There's already a Properties option in the context menu for mass edits. I think that's sufficient. 10. Can you clarify? 11. Agreed, but this is a whole separate issue re. metadata lookup for video/tv already covered elsewhere.

petr 2020-05-22 00:06 developer ~0058176	re 8: Fixed re 9: user can click on empty artwork and default 'image search' will be called .... isn't that enough ?

rusty 2020-05-22 00:14 administrator ~0058177	9. Yes that's sufficient. Tagging as resolved for Peke to verify.

rusty 2020-05-22 22:16 administrator ~0058205	Verified 8. Leaving as resolved for Peke to verify whether the remaining items he'd entered are sufficiently addressed by the various other bugs.

peke 2020-05-23 20:49 developer ~0058227 Last edited: 2020-05-23 23:07	1. 0016640 It is a good start to unify behavior our Auto Tools (eg. Tag from Filename/Auto tag online) 2. Added note ~58226 to clarify as like Petr pointed it is more UI issue than Functionality issue 3. Unable to replicate anymore 4. OK, lets leave it as is for now. 5. Agree it can be confusing, further improvements are handled in 0016642 6. Yes, it is covered in 0016640 7. Yes, Properties Multi Edit do for values locally in Library, this this was intended to solve/port/improve multi edit on fly eg. to quickly edit Selected added to 0016640 8. Confirmed verified 2251 9. Works in 2251, initially I could not click on Album art to either trigger old vs. new dialog or start image search. If I am able to replicate again will open new bug. 10. Explained in bug 0016649 11. as pointed in ~58226 Current columns are missing many fields that are important to tagging. This point is to add Different pre-selected colums based on type or if possible it would be the best that Auto-Tag pickup enabled columns from view which initiated Auto-Tag (this apply for both Auto-Tag Online/Filename) to be further clarified in 0016641

peke 2020-05-23 23:10 developer ~0058231	Verified 2251 Closing, all points are either fixed or documented in related bugs for future fix/improvements.