0002953: MP3: Some fields aren't saved to tags - MantisBT

ID	Project	Category	View Status	Date Submitted	Last Update

0002953	MMW v4	Properties/Auto-Tools	public	2007-03-27 20:41	2007-08-23 14:03

Reporter	rusty	Assigned To
Priority	urgent	Severity	major	Reproducibility	always
Status	resolved	Resolution	fixed
Product Version	3.0
Fixed in Version	3.0

Summary	0002953: MP3: Some fields aren't saved to tags
Description	The following fields aren't saved to the tag. They should be, in a standards-compliant manner (where possible): Disc# Conductor Album Gain Release Date (update from Year) -- did not test this
Additional Information	Please clearly document in the bug: 1) Any changes being made 2) A complete list of all MM Fields with associated Tag(s) being used in MM (this will be used to update user documentation) http://wiki.hydrogenaudio.org/index.php?title=Foobar2000:ID3_Tag_Mapping
Tags	No tags attached.

Fixed in build	1051

jiri 2007-03-27 22:07 administrator ~0008911	Some ideas in http://www.mediamonkey.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=9280

jiri 2007-04-12 15:00 administrator ~0008982 Last edited: 2007-04-12 15:12	The current mapping of fields to ID3v2 frames: Artist - TPE1 Album - TALB AlbumArtist - TPE2 Title - TIT2 Composer - TCOM Copyright - TCOP Encoded by - TENC (Currently not shown in MM UI) Lyricist - TEXT InvolvedPeople - IPLS ContentGroup - TIT1 (Currently not shown in MM UI) Subtitle - TIT3 (Currently not shown in MM UI) InitialKey - TKEY OriginalAlbum - TOAL OriginalArtist - TOPE OriginalLyricist - TOLY OriginalYear - TORY Track# - TRCK Publisher - TPUB ISRC - TSRC Encoder settings (a.k.a. encoder) - TSSE Lyrics (unsynchronized) - USLT Rating - POPM Comment - COMM Date (Year) - TDRC + TYER Genre - TCON BPM - TBPM Tempo, Occasion, Preference - COMM (with descriptions: Songs-DB_Tempo, Songs-DB_Occasion, Songs-DB_Preference) Mood - TMOO Custom1-5 - COMM (with descriptions: 'Songs-DB_Custom1', ...) Album art - APIC Volume leveling (track+album+track peak): RVA2, RGAD, TXXX (with descriptions: 'replaygain_track_gain', 'replaygain_track_peak' and 'replaygain_album_gain')

jiri 2007-04-12 15:26 administrator ~0008983 Last edited: 2007-04-12 15:29	Added in build 1028: Disc# - TPOS Conductor - TPE3

jiri 2007-04-12 16:13 administrator ~0008985 Last edited: 2007-04-12 16:28	Considering this as resolved for now. Some ideas from http://www.mediamonkey.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=9280 could still be implemented, but most of them would require more complex changes (support for new things, etc.) Things that would probably make sense: 1. REMOVE Custom fields from here COMM - make them into TXXX frames and use some better descriptions (not Songs-DB_...). 2. IPLS: Transfer this info to the new TIPL frame. IPLS is obsolete. - Since we store in ID3v2.3, it actually isn't obsolete. That said, we should consider whether we want to enhance the support for credits, i.e. add some better UI for entering things like: Guitar-His Name, Vocals-Her Name, etc. and add support for its storage to ID3 3. PCNT: Playcounter. MM writes this info only into the database - add it to the file, too. - Do we need this? If we implement it, it should be only optional, people wouldn't like tag updates after any playback... 4. TIT1: Work title, TIT3: Subtitle. Show there fields in MM UI? 5. TLAN: Language (must be stated in 3 letter code per ISO-639-2) - probably not a bad idea. 6. TPE2: Should really, really be "Band" or "Orchestra. "Album Artist" should be made into a TXXX frame. - Generally speaking, this is truth, but on the other hand, do we want to store Album Artists to non-standard frames? I'd say that TPE2 because de-facto standard for this purpose...

rusty 2007-07-16 19:57 administrator ~0009810	Tested 1049. Disc# doesn't seem to be saved to the tag.

jiri 2007-07-17 15:11 administrator ~0009826	Fixed in build 1051. - The Disc # was incorrectly decreased by 1.